A state church? A consideration of the Methodist Church of Southern Africa in the light of Dietrich Bonhoeffer’s ‘Theological position paper on state and church’.

Dion Angus Forster


This paper considers whether South Africa’s largest mainline Christian denomination, the Methodist Church of Southern Africa, is in danger of embodying or propagating a contemporary form of ‘state theology’. The notion of state theology in the South African context gained prominence through the publication of the ‘Kairos Document’ (1985) – which celebrated its 30th anniversary in 2015. State theology is deemed inappropriate and harmful to the identity and work of both the Christian church and the nation state. This paper presents its consideration of whether the Methodist Church of Southern Africa is in danger of propagating ‘state theology’ in dialogue with Dietrich Bonhoeffer’s important document, Theological Position Paper on State and Church. The paper offers some insights into the complex relationship between the state and the church in South Africa in the apartheid and democratic eras. It further problematises the relationship between the Methodist Church of Southern Africa and the governing African National Congress by citing some concerning examples of complicit behaviour from recent history. The MCSA’s polity and doctrine on church and state relationships are also considered before some critique and warning is offered in the light of Bonhoeffer’s Theological Position Paper on State and Church.


Dietrich Bonhoeffer; Methodism, Methodist; Wesleyan; South Africa; Church and State; Political Theology; Public Theology


Andrews, D.E. 2010. The Methodists and Revolutionary America, 1760-1800: The Shaping of an Evangelical Culture. Princeton University Press.

Bentley, W. 2013. Defining Christianity’s “prophetic witness” in the post-apartheid South African democracy. Studia Historiae Ecclesiasticae, 39(1).

Bentley, W. & Forster, D.A. 2012. Between Capital and Cathedral: Essays on Church-State relationships. Pretoria: UNISA Research Institute for Theology and Religion.

Boesak, A.A. 2015. Kairos, Crisis, and Global Apartheid: The Challenge to Prophetic Resistance. Palgrave Macmillan.

Bosch, L.C. 1995. The ethical implications of the concept of faith as freedom from society in the theology of John Wesley. University of South Africa.

Conradie, E.M. & Pillay, M. 2015. Ecclesial Reform and Deform Movements in the South African Context. AFRICAN SUN MeDIA.

De Gruchy, J.W. 2007. Public Theology as Christian Witness: Exploring the Genre. International Journal of Public Theology, 1(1):26–41.

———. 2005. The Church Struggle in South Africa. Twenty-fifth anniversary ed., 1st Fortress Press ed. Minneapolis: Fortress Press.

De Gruchy, J.W. & Villa-Vicencio, C. 1983. Apartheid is a heresy. Grand Rapids, Mich.: William B. Eerdmans Publishing Co.

Elphick, R. 2012. The Equality of Believers: Protestant Missionaries and the Racial Politics of South Africa. University of Virginia Press.

Elphick, R. & Davenport, T.R.H. 1997. Christianity in South Africa: A Political, Social, and Cultural History. University of California Press.

Field, D. 2015. John Wesley as a Public Theologian – The Case of Thoughts upon Slavery. Scriptura: International Journal of Bible, Religion and Theology in Southern Africa,.

Forrester, D.B., Storrar, W. & Morton, A. 2004. Public Theology for the 21st Century: Essays in Honour of Duncan B. Forrester. A&C Black.

Forster, D.A. 2008a. God’s mission in our context: Critical questions, healing and transforming responses., in Bentley, W. & Forster, D.A. (eds.). Methodism in Southern Africa: A celebration of Wesleyan mission. Kempton Park: AcadSA Publishers. 70–99.

———. 2014. Mandela and the Methodists: Faith, fallacy and fact. Studia Historiae Ecclesiasticae, 40(Church History Society of Southern Africa 40th Anniversary supplement):87–115.

———. 2008b. Prophetic witness and social action as holiness in the Methodist Church of Southern Africa’s mission. Studia Historiae Ecclesiasticae, XXXIV,(1):411–434.

———. 2015. What hope is there for South Africa? A public theological reflection on the role of the church as a bearer of hope for the future. HTS Teologiese Studies / Theological Studies, 71(1):1–10.

Forster, D.A. & Oosterbrink, J.W. 2015. Where is the church on Monday? Awakening the church to the theology and practice of ministry and mission in the marketplace. In die Skriflig/In Luce Verbi, 49(3).

Gish, S.D. 1985. The Methodist Church and apartheid in South Africa: a paper. Northwestern University.

Grass, T. 2008. Modern church history. SCM Press.

Green, C.J. & DeJonge, M., eds. 2013. The Bonhoeffer Reader. Fortress Press.

Hansen, L.D. 2007. Christian in public aims, methodologies, and issues in public theology. 1st ed. Stellenbosch: SUN Press.

Hendriks, J. & Erasmus, J. 2005. Religion in South Africa: 2001 population census data. Journal of Theology for Southern Africa, 121:88–111.

Huber, W. & Fourie, W. 2012. Christian Responsibility and Communicative Freedom: A Challenge for the Future of Pluralistic Societies : Collected Essays. LIT Verlag Münster.

Kairos Theologians. 1985. Challenge to the Church: A Theological Comment on the Political Crisis in South Africa. Johannesburg: Kairos Theologians.

Kalley, J.A., Schoeman, E. & Andor, L.E. 1999. Southern African Political History: A Chronology of Key Political Events from Independence to Mid-1997. Greenwood Publishing Group.

Kim, S.C.H. 2011. Theology in the Public Sphere. Hymns Ancient and Modern Ltd.

Maluleke, T.S. 2011. Reflections and Resources The Elusive Public of Public Theology: A Response to William Storrar. International Journal of Public Theology, 5(1):79–89.

Mandela, N. 1998. SA History Address by President Nelson Mandela at the first Triennial Conference of the Methodist church of South Africa [Online]. Available: http://www.sahistory.org.za/article/address-president-nelson-mandela-first-triennial-conference-methodist-church-south-africa.

———. 1994. Address by President Nelson Mandela to the Annual Conference of the Methodist Church [Online]. Speech. Available: http://www.anc.org.za/show.php?id=3685 [2011, January 4].

Marrian, N. 2015. Citizens’ confidence in state sinks to new low. Business Day Live,. Available: http://www.bdlive.co.za/national/2015/09/21/citizens-confidence-in-state-sinks-to-new-low [2015, September 26].

Mataboge, M. 2015. ANC hopes Methodists will minister to them. Mail & Guardian,. Available: http://mg.co.za/article/2015-05-26-the-methodist-church-may-no-longer-forsake-the-anc/ [2015, September 17].

Mehana, V. 2011. Zuma’s remarks explained - ANC Chaplain General [Online]. Available: http://www.politicsweb.co.za/politicsweb/view/politicsweb/en/page71639?oid=220386&sn=Detail&pid=71639.

Methodist Book of Order: The Laws and Discipline of the Methodist Church of Southern Africa. 2014. Cape Town: Methodist Publishing House.

Missouri, J.W.A.P. of H.U. of. 2009. American Saint : Francis Asbury and the Methodists: Francis Asbury and the Methodists. Oxford University Press, USA.

Mtshiselwa, N. 2015. The emergence of the Black Methodist Consultation and its possible prophetic voice in post-apartheid South Africa: original research. HTS: Theological Studies, 71(3):1–9.

Nico Koopman. 2011. Modes of prophecy in a democracy, in Heinrich Bedford-Strohm & Etienne de Villiers (eds.). Prophetic witness: an Appropriate Mode of Public Discourse in Democratic Societies?. Theology in the Public Square / Theologie in der Offentlichkeit, LIT Verlag. 181–192.

Nieman, A. 2010. Churches and social development in South Africa, in Swart, I. (Naas) W., Rocher, H., Erasmus, J. & Green, S. (eds.). Religion and social development in post-apartheid South Africa. Stellenbosch, South Africa: SUN Press. 37–44.

Phakathi, B. 2014. Pastors will not help ANC win votes, says DA [Online]. Available: http://www.bdlive.co.za/national/politics/2014/02/06/pastors-will-not-help-anc-win-votes-says-da.

Philander, N.C. 2011. Die rol van die kerk as een van die instellings in die samelewing wat mense moreel vorm. Dutch Reformed Theological Journal / Nederduitse Gereformeerde Teologiese Tydskrif, 52(1 & 2):174–185.

Plaatjies-Van Huffel, M.-A. & Vosloo, R. 2013. Reformed Churches in South Africa and the Struggle for Justice: Remembering 1960-1990. Stellenbosch, South Africa: AFRICAN SUN MeDIA.

Prozeky, M. 2009. Is the secular state the root of our moral problems in South Africa? Alternation, 3.

Rack, H.D. 1992. Reasonable enthusiast: John Wesley and the rise of Methodism. Epworth.

Richey, R.E. 2015. Methodism in the American Forest. Oxford University Press.

Smit, D.J. 2007. Essays in Public Theology: Collected Essays 1. Stellenbosch, South Africa: AFRICAN SUN MeDIA.

———. 1996. Oor die kerk as ’n unieke samelewingsverband. Tydskrif vir Geesteswetenskappe, 2(36):119–129.

———. 2013. The Paradigm of Public Theology - Origins and Development Bedford-Strohm, H., Höhne, F. & Reitmeier, T. (eds.). Contextuality and Intercontextuality in Public Theology,:11–23.

Statement on the Politicization of Religion and Rights of Religious Minorities. 2013. 6 Busan, Republic of Korea: World Council of Churches.

Storey, P. 2012. Banning the flag from our churches: Learning from the Church-State struggle in South Africa, in Forster, D.A. & Bentley, W. (eds.). Between Capital and Cathedral: Essays on Church and State Relationships. Pretoria: UNISA Research Institute for Theology and Religion. 1–20.

Tandwa, L. 2016. SACC is just a government mouthpiece - student leaders. Available: http://www.news24.com/SouthAfrica/News/sacc-is-just-a-govt-mouthpiece-student-leaders-20160119.

Tracy, D. 1975. Theology as public discourse. The Christian Century, 92(10):287–287.

———. 2014. Three Kinds of Publicness in Public Theology. International Journal of Public Theology, 8(3):330–334.

Tshaka R.S. 2014. A perspective on notions of spirituality, Democracy, Social cohesion and public theology. Verbum Ecclesia Verbum et Ecclesia, 35(3).

Vickers, J.A. 2013. Thomas Coke: Apostle of Methodism. Wipf and Stock Publishers.

Wesley, J. 1931. 8 The Letters of the Rev. John Wesley. Telford, J. (ed.). London: Epworth Press.

———. 1872. The Works of John Wesley. Jackson, T. (ed.). Zondervan.


  • There are currently no refbacks.

Copyright (c) 2016 Pieter de Waal Neethling Trust, Stellenbosch

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.

ISSN 2413-9467 (online); ISSN 2413-9459 (print)

© 2017 Pieter de Waal Neethling Trust, Stellenbosch.

No registration, article submission or processing fees apply.

This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited. 

SUMMARY: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ 
FULL: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/legalcode

Powered by OJS.