Stellenbosch Theological Journal 2024, Vol 10, No 2, 1–22
DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.17570/stj.2024.v10n2.15
Online ISSN 2226-2385 | Print ISSN 2413-9459
2024 © The Author(s)
Harmony in holistic healing: Integrating pastoral care and professional counselling for improved mental health in Gaborone, Botswana
University of South Africa (Unisa)
madigeletj@ub.ac.bw
Abstract
This article examines the integration of pastoral care and professional counselling to improve mental health in Gaborone, Botswana, a city facing rising mental health issues due to rapid urbanization. It advocates for a comprehensive, culturally sensitive model that incorporates traditional healing practices, evidence-based counselling, and community engagement. Using an Integrative Humanistic and Transpersonal framework, the article identifies gaps in existing mental health services through a literature review, emphasizing the need for culturally aligned approaches. Recommendations include collaboration with local stakeholders, capacity building for pastoral caregivers, and strategies to increase community engagement and reduce stigma. The approach highlights the interconnectedness of mind, body, and spirit for sustainable mental health improvement in an urban setting.
Keywords
Pastoral care; counselling; holistic healing; urbanization; mental health
In modern urban settings, mental health challenges have become increasingly prevalent, driven by the pressures of urbanization, socio-economic disparities, and the breakdown of traditional community structures. Globally, mental health disorders affect more than 300 million people, contributing to significant disability and hardship across all demographic lines (Srivastava, 2009). In Africa, the impact of mental health challenges is pronounced, with depression affecting over 29.19 million people, which accounts for 9 percent of the continent’s population (Gbadamosi et al. 2022). Botswana, like many other African nations, faces significant gaps in mental health care, particularly in urban environments like Gaborone, where stigma and lack of access hinder the effective delivery of services (Opondo et al. 2020). This paper seeks to address these challenges by exploring the integration of pastoral care and professional counselling as a potential model for addressing mental health needs in urban populations.
Gaborone’s mental health crisis is deeply intertwined with broader socio-economic challenges such as unemployment, poverty, and social isolation, which are exacerbated by rapid urbanization (Siamisang et al. 2022). Economic fluctuations and financial hardships contribute to the high prevalence of anxiety and depression, while the lack of strong social support systems further complicates the mental health landscape (Opondo et al. 2020). Addressing these challenges requires a comprehensive approach that includes both socio-economic assessments and therapeutic interventions. This paper argues that integrating pastoral care with professional counselling offers a promising avenue for addressing these challenges, providing a holistic model of mental health care that integrates spiritual, emotional, and psychological support.
A crucial aspect of this integrated model is the clear delineation of the different yet interconnected concepts of “professional counselling,” “holistic counselling,” “evidence-based counselling,” and “pastoral care”. Professional counselling is defined as a structured, ethical practice aimed at fostering mental health, wellness, and personal development through systematic methodologies. It emphasizes the use of evidence-based counselling, which employs interventions and strategies supported by empirical research, ensuring the effectiveness and integrity of therapeutic interventions (Perron et al 2023). Holistic counselling, on the other hand, integrates multiple dimensions of a person’s experience – emotional, psychological, physical, and spiritual – recognizing the interconnectedness of these aspects in the therapeutic process (Jasemi et al. 2017). Finally, pastoral care encompasses spiritual and emotional guidance, often provided within community and religious contexts, and is aimed at addressing an individual’s full potential, particularly in settings where mental health services are underutilized (Harrad et al. 2019).
The intersection of these approaches presents a comprehensive framework for mental health intervention in Gaborone. While professional counselling focuses on evidence-based and ethical practices, pastoral care provides the spiritual and community support that is often crucial in addressing mental health stigma and promoting service utilization. Together, these approaches can offer a culturally sensitive and responsive model of care that aligns with Botswana’s unique social and spiritual landscape.
This paper will explore the benefits of this integrated approach, examine the role of stigma in the underutilization of mental health services, and consider how pastoral caregivers can help mitigate these challenges. This research aims to contribute to the broader understanding of mental health care in Botswana and similar contexts, offering insights that may inform policy and practice to enhance the mental health support available to urban populations facing significant socio-economic and cultural challenges.
Mental health is a state of mental well-being that encompasses the emotional, psychological, and social aspects of an individual’s life. It involves the ability to cope with stress, realize personal abilities, function effectively in daily activities, and contribute positively to one’s community. Mental health is more than just the absence of mental disorders; it exists on a complex continuum experienced differently by individuals. Factors influencing mental health include biological and psychological elements, social determinants such as economic status and environmental conditions, as well as exposure to adverse life events. Protective factors like social support, emotional skills, and positive environments can enhance resilience against mental health risks (WHO 2018).
Furthermore, mental health is not a static state, but rather a dynamic process that evolves and can be influenced by various internal and external factors. The World Health Organization (WHO) views mental health as a tripartite value proposition, essential for individual well-being, community welfare, and socio-economic advancement (WHO, 2022). This statement implies that mental health is not only important for the well-being of individuals but also plays a crucial role in benefiting communities and contributing to socio-economic development. In other words, mental health has a threefold significance: it is essential for the personal happiness and functioning of individuals, it impacts the overall welfare and functioning of communities, and it has implications for the economic progress and prosperity of societies. This perspective emphasizes the interconnectedness of mental health with various aspects of life and highlights its broad-reaching effects beyond the individual level.
In addition, mental health covers a range of conditions such as mental disorders, psychosocial disabilities, distress, impaired functioning, and the risk of self-harm, among others. Individuals who are dealing with these conditions may experience a decrease in their mental well-being at times (WHO 2022).
Mental health care emerges as a comprehensive and collaborative endeavour that seeks to promote mental well-being, prevent mental disorders, and provide evidence-based treatment and support services to individuals in need. This multi-faceted approach underlines the importance of addressing mental health from a holistic perspective, considering the individual, societal, and environmental factors that impact mental well-being (WHO 2022).
Mental health care, with its emphasis on promoting mental well-being, preventing mental disorders, and delivering evidence-based treatment and support services, aligns closely with the principles of Botho and Pastoral Theology. The concept of Botho is a fundamental aspect of African philosophy that emphasizes the values of humanity, community, and the interconnectedness of individuals within a social context. Botho places a high premium on relationships, mutual respect, empathy, and the collective well-being of the community. This philosophy is expressed in the Setswana saying, Motho ke motho ka batho ba bangwe, meaning, “A person is a person through others,” which emphasises the idea that individual identity and fulfilment are deeply rooted in one’s connection to the broader community (Gaie et al. 2008).
Botho shares profound similarities with the well-known South African concept of Ubuntu, a term derived from the Nguni languages, which conveys a similar understanding of communal interdependence. Ubuntu is often summarized by the phrase, “I am because we are,” which highlights the relational nature of human existence. This concept rejects individualism in favour of a collective identity, fostering a society where the well-being of one is inextricably linked to the well-being of all (Ramose 2002).
In the context of mental health care, the principles of Botho/Ubuntu provide a valuable framework for fostering compassionate, culturally sensitive, and relational approaches to healing. Both concepts advocate for the holistic care of individuals, considering not just their psychological needs but also their relational, spiritual, and communal contexts. When integrated with Pastoral Theology, which emphasizes care, compassion, and spiritual support grounded in religious teachings, Botho/Ubuntu creates a powerful model for mental health care that resonates deeply with African values and cultural practices (Lartey 2003; Patton 1993).
This integrated approach aligns with the emphasis on evidence-based counselling, which involves empirically validated interventions, and holistic counselling, which addresses the full spectrum of an individual’s experience – emotional, psychological, physical, and spiritual. By incorporating the principles of Botho/Ubuntu, mental health interventions can better serve African communities by honouring their cultural and philosophical traditions while delivering effective care. Pastoral care, in this context, becomes a bridge between traditional African values and modern therapeutic practices, fostering a more inclusive and holistic approach to mental health and well-being.
This blending of Botho/Ubuntu, Pastoral Theology, and professional counselling not only addresses the emotional and psychological needs of individuals but also reinforces the importance of community, relational harmony, and spiritual well-being in the healing process. As mental health care in urban settings like Gaborone evolves, this integrated model provides a culturally relevant and spiritually affirming foundation for fostering mental health and promoting communal harmony.
A holistic approach in healthcare involves considering the whole person – mind, body, and spirit – and addressing their physical, emotional, social, and spiritual needs to promote overall well-being. This approach recognizes the interconnectedness of various aspects of an individual’s life and aims to treat the person as a whole, rather than focusing solely on symptoms or specific health conditions (Madigele and Tabalaka 2023). It often involves personalized treatment plans that consider not only physical symptoms but also factors such as lifestyle, environment, emotions, and beliefs. Holistic healthcare providers therefore view individuals as unique beings with their own set of needs and experiences, and they strive to empower patients to take an active role in their health and healing process. By addressing the root causes of health issues and promoting self-care practices, holistic healthcare aims to support individuals in achieving balance and harmony in all aspects of their lives (Madigele 2023).
In counselling, a holistic approach considers individuals within the context of their relationships, communities, and environments. This perspective acknowledges that human behaviour is influenced by a complex interplay of factors, including biological, psychological, social, and cultural elements. By adopting a holistic approach, counsellors seek to understand the entirety of a person’s experiences and circumstances (Paredes et al, 2021). Professional counselling evolved to address the challenges and changes that the country was facing in the health and educational settings. The profession developed gradually into a fully developed profession and is increasingly offered in various settings such as non-government organizations (NGOs), government ministries, private agencies as well as community agencies.
For pastoral theology, the holistic approach recognizes the interconnectedness of physical, emotional, mental, and spiritual aspects of a person’s well-being and seeks to address these dimensions in a coordinated manner. It often involves pastoral counsellors, chaplains, or clergy members who are trained to provide pastoral care that encompasses the whole person. Pastoral care is a form of spiritual support which encompasses a range of practices aimed at addressing the spiritual, emotional, mental, and relational needs of individuals, often within the context of faith communities or healthcare settings (Janse van Rensburg 2010). Pastoral caregivers are trained to offer compassionate care that respects individuals’ autonomy, dignity, and spiritual beliefs.
One key aspect of the holistic pastoral approach is the recognition of the spiritual dimension of human existence. Another important element of the holistic pastoral approach is the emphasis on individualized care. Pastoral caregivers seek to understand each person’s unique circumstances, beliefs, values and needs to provide tailored support that respects their autonomy and dignity. This personalized approach helps foster trust and rapport between caregivers and those receiving care, leading to more effective therapeutic outcomes. Creating a welcoming environment is key in the counselling process that invites the clients to feel free to share their challenges without feeling judged. This approach also values collaboration and coordination among different professionals involved in a person’s care. This includes working closely with medical providers, mental health professionals, social workers, and other caregivers to ensure a comprehensive and cohesive support system for individuals in need (Janse van Rensburg 2010).
Botho also emphasizes the importance of viewing individuals as whole beings, considering not only their immediate needs but also their relationships, communities, and environments. The holistic approach’s emphasis on personalized care, empowerment of individuals, and consideration of root causes of health issues resonates with the values of Botho, which prioritize understanding and supporting each person’s unique circumstances, beliefs, and needs. By recognizing the spiritual dimension of human existence and fostering trust, respect, and collaboration among caregivers and individuals receiving care, the holistic approach reflects the principles of Botho in promoting holistic well-being and harmonious relationships within communities.
The interconnected concepts of Mental Health Care, the Holistic Approach, and Pastoral Care share common principles and approaches aimed at promoting overall well-being and addressing the multifaceted needs of individuals. These concepts are linked by their focus on holistic well-being, individualized care, and the acknowledgement of the interconnected nature of various aspects of an individual’s life. They all prioritize the comprehensive well-being of individuals and stress the importance of tailoring care to meet individual needs. Moreover, these concepts highlight the significance of collaboration and coordination among diverse professionals to deliver comprehensive support. This interconnectedness is also evident in the principles of Botho, emphasizing the importance of relationships, empathy, and communal harmony in fostering well-being. Pastoral care specifically recognizes the spiritual aspect of human existence and integrates spiritual beliefs into the healing process, aligning with the holistic approach’s consideration of the mind, body, and spirit in healthcare. Botho’s emphasis on interconnectedness further reinforces the holistic perspective by acknowledging the spiritual, emotional, and social dimensions of well-being (Madigele 2023).
Humanistic psychology is proposed within this theoretical framework. Humanistic psychology is a psychological perspective that emphasizes the inherent worth and potential for growth in individuals. It focuses on the importance of self-actualization, personal responsibility, and subjective experiences in understanding human behaviour. Humanistic psychologists believe that individuals have the capacity to make choices and strive towards fulfilling their unique potential.
Two prominent figures in humanistic psychology are Carl Rogers and Abraham Maslow. Carl Rogers is known for his person-centred approach to therapy, which emphasizes empathy, unconditional positive regard, and authenticity in the therapeutic relationship. Rogers believed that providing a supportive and non-judgmental environment allows individuals to explore their feelings and experiences, leading to personal growth and self-actualization (Rogers, 1980). Abraham Maslow on the other hand introduced the hierarchy of needs theory, which posits that individuals have a hierarchy of needs ranging from basic physiological needs to higher-level self-actualization needs. Maslow’s theory highlights the importance of fulfilling basic needs before individuals can progress towards realizing their full potential and achieving self-actualization (Maslow, 1968). Humanistic psychology provides a framework for understanding the interconnectedness of the physical, emotional, and spiritual well-being of individuals. The person-centred approach advocated by humanistic psychology resonates with the inclusive and compassionate care provided by the Christian Church, reflecting a shared commitment to addressing the holistic needs of individuals in healthcare settings.
This article also proposes transpersonal psychology within this theoretical framework. This is a subfield of psychology that explores the spiritual and transcendent aspects of human experience, going beyond the individual’s identity to encompass broader dimensions of consciousness and interconnectedness. It focuses on topics such as mindfulness, meditation, mystical experiences, and spiritual growth, aiming to integrate these aspects into the understanding of psychology and well-being. Two key figures in transpersonal psychology are Stanislav Grof and Ken Wilber. Stanislav Grof is known for his research on non-ordinary states of consciousness, such as those induced by psychedelic substances or deep meditative practices. Grof’s work explores the potential for healing and transformation through spiritual experiences and expanded states of awareness (Grof 1988). Ken Wilber on the other hand developed integral theory, which seeks to integrate various perspectives and approaches to understanding human consciousness and development. Integral theory emphasizes the interconnectedness of mind, body, and spirit, and the importance of addressing all aspects of the individual in promoting holistic well-being (Wilber 2000).
It is worth noting that pastoral theologians, such as Thomas Merton (2008), Howard Clinebell (1984), Emanuel Lartey (2003), and John Patton (1993), share a common goal with transpersonal psychologists like Stanislav Grof and Ken Wilber in exploring the spiritual and transcendent dimensions of human experience. These pastoral theologians emphasize the interconnectedness of mind, body, and spirit in their approach to pastoral care, recognizing the importance of addressing the holistic well-being of individuals. By integrating elements of transpersonal psychology into their work, they acknowledge the potential for healing and transformation through spiritual experiences, mindfulness, and expanded states of awareness. Both pastoral theologians and transpersonal psychologists aim to provide a more holistic understanding of human consciousness and development, promoting spiritual growth, healing, and wholeness in individuals by considering the interconnected nature of their experiences and the broader dimensions of consciousness.
Moreover, scholars like David Lukoff and Kenneth Pargament have contributed valuable insights to this field. David Lukoff’s work on spiritual competence in psychotherapy emphasizes the importance of therapists being aware of and sensitive to the spiritual beliefs and practices of their clients (Lukoff, Lu & Turner 1998). This approach recognizes that spirituality can be a vital source of strength and resilience for individuals facing mental health challenges. Lukoff’s emphasis on spiritual competence in psychotherapy complements Lartey’s (2003) intercultural pastoral theology, which advocates for sensitivity and responsiveness to diverse cultural and spiritual traditions. Just as Lukoff encourages therapists to recognize the spiritual dimension of their clients’ experiences, Lartey promotes an understanding of different cultural and spiritual contexts in pastoral care, affirming the need for ministers to approach pastoral work with awareness and respect for the variety of beliefs and practices that shape people’s identities.
Moreover, Kenneth Pargament’s research on the role of spirituality in coping with stress and trauma highlights how spiritual beliefs and practices can provide a sense of meaning, purpose, and connection, contributing to better mental health outcomes (Pargament 1997). Similarly, Lartey’s (2003) intercultural pastoral theology recognizes the importance of spirituality as a resource for healing across different cultural contexts. Both scholars stress that spirituality, whether through prayer, ritual, or communal support, can offer individuals a sense of meaning, purpose, and resilience in the face of adversity.
The integration of both humanistic and transpersonal psychology aligns with the principles of Botho, a popular Setswana cultural model which emphasizes on inclusivity, compassion, and the interconnected nature of individuals’ well-being. Botho/Ubuntu could be viewed as cultural equivalents to self-actualization in humanistic psychology. These philosophies emphasize the individual’s responsibility to themselves and their community, mirroring Maslow’s hierarchy of needs in their focus on achieving personal and communal fulfilment. This suggests that a hybrid model of care, rooted in both Western psychological theory and African cultural values, could provide a more accessible and acceptable form of mental health care in Botswana. The cultural sensitivity approach advocated by Lartey and Lukoff must go beyond simple acknowledgement of spirituality. Rather, it must actively incorporate the rituals, symbols, and communal practices that are central to the Batswana understanding of well-being and healing.
Pastoral theologians and transpersonal psychologists share the goal of exploring spiritual dimensions for healing and transformation. By integrating spirituality into mental health care, practitioners can offer comprehensive and culturally sensitive interventions that address the multidimensional aspects of human well-being, promoting healing and growth in the context of mental health challenges.
One of the primary contributors to mental health issues in Gaborone is the prevalence of socio-economic challenges. Botswana, particularly an urban centre like Gaborone, has experienced rapid economic growth and urbanization over recent decades. However, this urbanization has not been without its drawbacks. High levels of unemployment, particularly among young people, create financial instability, which in turn leads to increased stress and anxiety. According to Mogomotsi and Madigele (2017), unemployment in urban areas has been identified as a significant factor contributing to anxiety and depression, as people struggle to meet basic needs and deal with societal pressures to succeed. Poverty and inequality further exacerbate mental health problems, with individuals from lower socio-economic backgrounds facing greater challenges accessing adequate healthcare services, including mental health care (Phaladze & Tlou 2006).
Additionally, Gaborone’s increasing urbanization has led to rising housing costs and overcrowding, particularly in informal settlements. These living conditions often lack access to basic services, such as clean water and sanitation, which further contribute to stress. A study by Sinharoy et al. (2019) indicated that individuals living in overcrowded and unsanitary environments were more likely to experience symptoms of anxiety and depression compared to those living in more stable and well-serviced areas. These socio-economic pressures have created an environment where mental health issues are not only prevalent but also poorly addressed.
Cultural attitudes toward mental health in Botswana also play a significant role in shaping the mental health landscape. Mental illness is often highly stigmatized, with many associating it with spiritual or supernatural causes. Traditional beliefs attribute mental health issues to witchcraft or punishment for transgressions, leading to social isolation of individuals suffering from mental health disorders. The cultural attitudes toward mental health in Botswana, have a profound impact on health-seeking behaviours. These beliefs contribute to significant stigma surrounding mental health issues, often leading individuals, and families to delay or avoid seeking professional help. Many people may instead turn to traditional healers or religious leaders for treatment, reinforcing the belief that mental health issues are spiritual rather than medical (Opondo et al 2020). This worldview complicates efforts to introduce more Western-centric therapeutic models, which often prioritize individual agency, rationality, and medical explanations of mental health.
This stigma also leads to social isolation of those affected by mental health disorders, as communities often fear the perceived spiritual implications of associating with such individuals. As a result, people with mental health challenges often suffer in silence or are excluded from communal life, which exacerbates their conditions. The fear of being labelled as bewitched or punished by higher powers discourages open conversations about mental health and contributes to a reluctance to engage with mental health services, which are already limited in many parts of the country. This stigma poses a significant barrier to the effectiveness of mental health interventions (Becker et al. 2019). Moreover, the fear of being labelled as “mad” prevents many from seeking help, thereby worsening their condition. This stigma is further exacerbated by limited public education on mental health, leaving many people unaware of the symptoms of mental illness and the available treatment options (Fusar-Poli et al. 2024).
In Gaborone, this stigma is prevalent across different demographics, affecting men and women differently. Men are often discouraged from expressing their emotions or seeking help for mental health issues due to traditional notions of masculinity, which value stoicism and resilience. Women, on the other hand, may experience a double burden, as they are expected to maintain their roles within the family while also dealing with the pressures of modern life, leading to increased rates of depression (Becker et al., 2019). These cultural barriers to seeking help are a significant challenge to improving mental health outcomes in Gaborone.
Another critical challenge contributing to mental health issues in Gaborone is the limited access to mental health services. Despite Botswana’s relatively strong healthcare system, mental health care remains underdeveloped and underfunded. There is a shortage of trained mental health professionals, with only a few psychiatrists and psychologists serving the entire country. While there are some private mental health practitioners, their services are often inaccessible to the majority of the population due to high costs. Additionally, public mental health services are limited, and individuals requiring mental health care often have to wait long periods before receiving treatment (Mangwegape et al. 2024).
Furthermore, mental health services in Gaborone are concentrated in urban centres, leaving individuals in rural areas with limited access. This geographic disparity exacerbates the challenge of addressing mental health issues across the population. Even within urban areas like Gaborone, access to mental health care is often complicated by logistical barriers, such as long travel distances to clinics or a lack of transportation. A study by Sidandi et al, (2011) highlighted the need for decentralization of mental health services and improved integration of mental health care into primary healthcare services to increase accessibility.
Meanwhile, Gaborone’s rapid urbanization has led to shifts in the traditional social structure, with many people moving away from rural communities and extended family networks to live in the city. This migration has contributed to increased social isolation, as individuals often leave behind strong support systems to pursue economic opportunities in the urban centre. Social isolation is a known risk factor for mental health disorders, including depression and anxiety. In Gaborone, the breakdown of traditional family structures has been associated with rising rates of depression, particularly among older adults who feel disconnected from their families (Griffiths, 2024).
Moreover, the fast-paced, modern lifestyle in Gaborone has led to increased levels of stress among residents. The pressures of maintaining employment, financial stability, and personal relationships in a rapidly changing environment can lead to burnout and contribute to the onset of anxiety disorders. Many people in Gaborone feel overwhelmed by the demands of urban life and struggle to cope with the increasing complexities of their environment (Modie-Moroka 2014).
The high prevalence of HIV and AIDS in Botswana, particularly in urban areas like Gaborone, has had a profound impact on the mental health of the population. Botswana has one of the highest HIV prevalence rates in the world, with significant implications for the mental health of those living with the virus. People living with HIV are at an increased risk of developing mental health disorders, including depression and anxiety, due to the chronic stress of managing the illness, societal stigma, and the fear of mortality (Siamisang et al 2022). The mental health burden is further compounded by the stigma associated with HIV, which discourages individuals from seeking both physical and mental health care. In Gaborone, where HIV prevalence is high, the mental health needs of people living with HIV are often unmet due to the focus on managing the physical aspects of the disease. The Ministry of Health and Wellness has recognized the need for more comprehensive care that addresses both the physical and mental health needs of individuals living with HIV, but challenges remain in implementing these services (Siamisang et al 2022).
The integration of pastoral care and professional counselling in Gaborone, Botswana, offers a unique and promising avenue for addressing the mental health challenges within the community. As highlighted in the literature, Gaborone faces complex socio-economic, cultural, and health-related issues that exacerbate mental health disorders. These challenges include stigma towards mental illness, socio-economic stressors such as unemployment and poverty, urbanization, and the breakdown of traditional social support systems. Furthermore, the high prevalence of HIV and AIDS continues to significantly burden mental health, creating a dire need for a holistic and culturally sensitive approach to care.
Traditional beliefs, which often link mental illness to spiritual or supernatural causes, can deter individuals from seeking professional help, as many associate mental health disorders with witchcraft or divine punishment. The stigma associated with mental illness further entrenches social isolation, limiting both communal support and access to professional care. In this context, pastoral care, rooted in the principles of botho (or ubuntu), offers a culturally resonant model of healing that emphasizes compassion, interconnectedness, and the inherent dignity of individuals. This model aligns well with humanistic psychology, which centres on the holistic growth of individuals and their potential for self-actualization. The humanistic emphasis on empathy, unconditional positive regard, and the therapeutic relationship can help dismantle the stigma surrounding mental health by reframing mental illness as a human experience rather than a supernatural affliction. The integration of transpersonal psychology within this framework offers an even deeper alignment with Botswana’s spiritual traditions. Transpersonal psychology, which seeks to incorporate spiritual experiences into the understanding of human consciousness, provides a theoretical foundation for pastoral care to address the spiritual and transcendent dimensions of mental health. In this way, spiritual beliefs are not dismissed but rather integrated into the healing process, allowing individuals to draw strength and meaning from their faith traditions. This approach mirrors the work of Emmanuel Lartey (2003), whose intercultural pastoral theology stresses the importance of cultural sensitivity in pastoral care, particularly in diverse and spiritually rich environments like Botswana.
As the urbanization of Gaborone accelerates, new challenges arise, including unemployment, housing instability, and the erosion of traditional familial structures. These socio-economic stressors contribute to heightened levels of anxiety and depression, particularly among marginalized groups such as unemployed youth and women facing economic hardships. Pastoral care, with its focus on community support and spiritual well-being, offers an avenue for reconnecting individuals to support networks that have been disrupted by urban migration.
The integration of professional counselling within this framework provides the necessary psychological expertise to address these issues in a clinically effective manner. Professional counselling, particularly when informed by humanistic and transpersonal approaches, can help individuals navigate the psychological impacts of socio-economic stress, while pastoral care can address the emotional and spiritual dimensions of their experiences. Together, these approaches offer a comprehensive model for mental health intervention that is responsive to both the psychological and socio-economic realities of urban life in Gaborone.
The high prevalence of HIV in Botswana has profound mental health implications, particularly in urban areas like Gaborone, where the disease is more prevalent. People living with HIV often face stigma, isolation, and chronic stress, which contribute to mental health disorders such as depression and anxiety. The focus of HIV care in Botswana has traditionally been on the physical management of the disease, with limited attention to the mental health needs of those affected. Integrating pastoral care and professional counselling into HIV care presents an opportunity to address these unmet mental health needs. Pastoral care can offer emotional and spiritual support to individuals grappling with the existential and spiritual challenges posed by the disease, while professional counselling can provide psychological interventions to manage the mental health symptoms associated with HIV. This integrative approach reflects the holistic healing emphasized in both humanistic and transpersonal psychology, ensuring that the full spectrum of individuals’ needs be it physical, psychological, and spiritual are met.
The success of integrating pastoral care and professional counselling for mental health in Gaborone hinges on addressing several systemic challenges. First, there is a need for increased collaboration between religious leaders, traditional healers, and mental health professionals to foster mutual respect and understanding. Religious leaders and pastors often serve as first points of contact for individuals experiencing mental health issues, and their involvement in a formalized care structure can bridge the gap between spiritual and medical models of healing.
Second, there is a pressing need for increased training in both pastoral and professional settings. Pastors and church leaders must be equipped with basic mental health competencies, including the ability to recognize signs of mental illness and make appropriate referrals to mental health professionals. Similarly, professional counsellors must be trained in cultural and spiritual sensitivity to effectively incorporate clients’ faith traditions into treatment plans.
Thirdly, pastoral care providers and professional counsellors can engage with the community to raise awareness about mental health, reduce stigma, and promote help-seeking behaviours. By offering educational workshops, support groups, and outreach programs, they can create safe spaces for individuals to discuss mental health concerns and access appropriate care. Community involvement enhances the reach and impact of mental health services in urban areas like Gaborone (Agarwal et al. 2019).
Finally, collaboration between pastoral care providers, professional counsellors, mental health professionals, and community organizations is essential for a coordinated and effective approach to mental health care. By working together, sharing expertise, and pooling resources, stakeholders can develop innovative interventions, advocate for policy changes, and address systemic barriers to mental health support in urban environments (WHO 2023). This integrated model has the potential to enhance mental health care delivery, reduce stigma, and promote well-being in urban communities. These reforms are necessary to expand access to mental health services across both urban and rural areas. Public health campaigns can help reduce the stigma surrounding mental health by educating the public on the signs and symptoms of mental illness and promoting the benefits of seeking care from both pastoral and professional sources.
Conclusion
The integration of pastoral care and professional counselling represents a promising pathway toward addressing the mental health challenges in Gaborone, Botswana. By drawing on the strengths of both humanistic and transpersonal psychology and aligning these approaches with the cultural values of Botho, a more holistic model of care can emerge – one that is attuned to the spiritual, emotional, and psychological dimensions of well-being. In this way, Botswana can move toward a more inclusive and effective mental health care system that embraces both the professional expertise of counsellors and the cultural and spiritual wisdom of pastoral care.
This integrative model holds the potential not only to alleviate the mental health burden in Gaborone but also to provide a culturally resonant framework for healing that harmonizes the diverse elements of Botswana’s mental, spiritual, and social landscape.
The integration of pastoral care and professional counselling presents a promising avenue for addressing mental health challenges in Gaborone. As we delve into suggestions for future research and practical applications, several key areas emerge that can further enhance the effectiveness and reach of this integrated approach. Longitudinal studies are essential to understanding the sustained impact of integrated pastoral care and professional counselling interventions on mental health outcomes in urban populations. By tracking individuals over an extended period, researchers can assess the long-term benefits of this combined approach, providing valuable insights into its efficacy and potential for promoting lasting well-being.
Bibliography
Agarwal, S.K., Chapron, C., Giudice, L.C., Laufer, M.R., Leyland, N., Missmer, S.A., Singh, S.S., & Taylor, H.S. 2019. Clinical diagnosis of endometriosis: a call to action. American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynaecology, 220(4):354. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ajog.2018.12.039.
Becker, T.D., Ho-Foster, A.R., Poku, O.B., Marobela, S., Mehta, H., Cao, D.T.X., Yang, L.S., Blank, L.I., Dipatane, V.I., Moeng, L.R., Molebatsi, K., Eisenberg, M.M., Barg, F.K., Blank, M.B., Opondo, P.R., & Yang, L.H. 2019. It’s when the trees blossom: Explanatory Beliefs, Stigma, and Mental Illness in the Context of HIV in Botswana. Qualitative Health Research, 29(11):1566–1580. https://doi.org/10.1177/1049732319827523.
Clinebell, H.J. 1984. Wellness Ministry: A Journey of Health, Healing and Holistic Care. Minneapolis, MN: Fortress Press.
Fusar-Poli, P., Estradé, A., Esposito, C.M., Rosfort, R., Basadonne, I., Mancini, M., Stanghellini, G., Otaiku, J., Olanrele, O., Allen, L., Lamba, M., Alaso, C., Ieri, J., Atieno, M., Oluoch, Y., Ireri, P., Tembo, E., Phiri, I.Z., Nkhoma, D., Sichone, N., ... Maj, M., 2024. The lived experience of mental disorders in adolescents: a bottom-up review co-designed, co-conducted and co-written by experts by experience and academics. World Psychiatry, 23(2):191–208. https://doi.org/10.1002/wps.21189.
Gaie, J.B.R. 2008. The Ethics of Medical Involvement in Capital Punishment: A Philosophical Discussion. Stellenbosch: African Sun Media.
Gbadamosi, I.T., Henneh, I.T., Aluko, O.M., Yawson, E.O., Fokoua, A.R., Koomson, A., Torbi, J., Olorunnado, S.E., Lewu, F.S., Yusha’u, Y., Keji-Taofik, S.T., Biney, R.P., & Tagoe, T.A. 2022. Depression in Sub-Saharan Africa. IBRO Neuroscience Reports, 12:309–322. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ibneur.2022.03.005.
Griffiths, A. 2024. Transformative spaces: peri-urban domains, legal pluralism and land in Botswana. Legal Pluralism and Critical Social Analysis, 56(1):13–32. https://doi.org/10.1080/27706869.2024.2312485.
Grof, S. 1988. The Adventure of Self-Discovery: Dimensions of Consciousness and New Perspectives in Psychotherapy and Inner Exploration. New York: State University of New York Press.
Harrad, R., Cosentino, C., Keasley, R., & Sulla, F. 2019. Spiritual care in nursing: an overview of the measures used to assess spiritual care provision and related factors amongst nurses. Acta Bio-medica: Atenei Parmensis, 90(4-S):44–55. https://doi.org/10.23750/abm.v90i4-S.8300.
Janse van Rensburg, J. 2010. A holistic approach to pastoral care and poverty. Verbum et Ecclesia, 31(1):7. https://doi.org/10.4102/ve.v31i1.386.
Jasemi, M., Valizadeh, L., Zamanzadeh, V., & Keogh, B. 2017. A concept analysis of holistic care by hybrid model. Indian Journal of Palliative Care, 23(1):71–80. https://doi.org/10.4103/0973-1075.197960.
Lukoff, D., Lu, F.G., & Turner, R.P. 1998. Toward a more culturally sensitive DSM-IV. Cultural Diversity and Mental Health, 4(1):38–48.
Lartey, E.Y. 2003. In Living Colour: An Intercultural Approach to Pastoral Care and Counseling. Jessica Kingsley Publishers.
Madigele, T.J. 2023. Pastoral Caregivers in Botswana Government Hospitals: A Holistic Pastoral Theological Approach. Journal for the Study of the Religions of Africa and its Diaspora, 6:66–75.
Madigele, T.J., & Tabalaka, A.B. 2023. Interprofessional Collaboration of Health Care Providers in Botswana: A Holistic Approach to Health Care. Journal for the Study of the Religions of Africa and its Diaspora, 6:52–65.
Maslow, A.H. 1968. Toward a Psychology of Being. New York: D. Van Nostrand Company.
Mangwegape, D.S., Manyedi, M.E., & Molato, B.J. 2024. Risk factors to mental health challenges among the LGBTI+ community in Gaborone, Botswana. Curationis, 47(1):a2543. https://doi.org/10.4102/curationis.v47i1.2543.
Maslow, A.H. 1968. Toward a Psychology of Being. New York: Van Nostrand.
Mogomotsi, G.E., & Madigele, P.K. 2017. A cursory discussion of policy alternatives for addressing youth unemployment in Botswana. Cogent Social Sciences, 3(1):1–9. https://doi.org/10.1080/23311886.2017.1356619.
Modie-Moroka, T. 2014. Stress, social relationships and health outcomes in low-income Francistown, Botswana. Social Psychiatry and Psychiatric Epidemiology, 49(8):1269–1277. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00127-013-0806-8.
Paredes, M.R., Apaolaza, V., Fernandez-Robin, C., Hartmann, P., & Yañez-Martinez, D. 2021. The impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on subjective mental well-being: The interplay of perceived threat, future anxiety and resilience. Personality and Individual Differences, 170, Article 110455. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.paid.2020.110455.
Pargament, K.I. 1997. The Psychology of Religion and Coping: Theory, Research, Practice. New York: Guilford Press.
Patton, J. 1993. Pastoral Care in Context: An Introduction to Pastoral Care. Westminster: John Knox Press.
Perron, N.C.D., Lim, V.H., Isenman, L., & Yamoah, K.G. 2023. International counselling values: Recognizing valued approaches identified by international counselling professionals through qualitative inquiry. International Journal for the Advancement of Counselling, 45(2):330–355. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10447-023-09505-4.
Phaladze, N., & Tlou, S. 2006. Gender and HIV/AIDS in Botswana: a focus on inequalities and discrimination. Gender & Development, 14(1):23–35. https://doi.org/10.1080/13552070500518095.
Ramose, M.B. 2002. African Philosophy through Ubuntu. Harare: Mond Books.
Rogers, C. 1980. A Way of Being. Palo Alto, CA: Houghton Mifflin.
Selimen, D., & Andsoy, I.I. 2011. The importance of a holistic approach during the perioperative period. AORN Journal, 93:482–487.
Siamisang, K., Kebadiretse, D., Tjirare, L.T., Muyela, C., Gare, K., & Masupe, T. 2022. Prevalence and predictors of depression, anxiety, and stress among frontline healthcare workers at COVID-19 isolation sites in Gaborone, Botswana. PLoS One, 17(8):e0273052. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0273052.
Sidandi, P., Opondo, P., & Tidimane, S. 2011. Mental health in Botswana. International Psychiatry: Bulletin of the Board of International Affairs of the Royal College of Psychiatrists, 8(3):66–68.
Sinharoy, S.S., Pittluck, R., & Clasen, T. 2019. Review of drivers and barriers of water and sanitation policies for urban informal settlements in low-income and middle-income countries. Utilities Policy, 60, Article 100957. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jup.2019.100957.
Srivastava, K. 2009. Urbanization and mental health. Industrial Psychiatry Journal, 18(2):75–76. https://doi.org/10.4103/0972-6748.64028.
World Health Organization (WHO), 2018. Mental Health. [Online]. Available: https://www.who.int/data/gho/data/themes/mental-health [Accessed: 12 March 2024].
World Health Organization (WHO), 2022. Mental Health: Strengthening Our Response. [Online]. Available: https://www.who.int/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/mental-health-strengthening-our-response [Accessed: 12 March 2024].
Wilber, K. 2000. Integral Psychology: Consciousness, Spirit, Psychology, Therapy. Boston, MA: Shambhala Publications.
World Health Organization (WHO), 2023. Botswana’s Investment in Primary Health Care Enhances Access and Quality of Health Care in the Country. [Online]. Available at: https://www.afro.who.int/countries/botswana/news/botswanas-investment-primary-health-care-enhances-access-and-quality-health-care-country [Accessed: 12 March 2024].
Wilber, K. 2000. A Theory of Everything: An Integral Vision for Business, Politics, Science and Spirituality. Boston, MA: Shambhala Publications.